Personal Branding for Writers
It’s been told and repeated over and over that writer’s job is to create some sort of personal brand in her online presence (thinking that, God forbid, nobody would even consider buying a book if the author doesn’t have a website!) and that this personal brand must show her as a generally “not an ass”, preferrably somebody nice, not offending anybody, not having too strong opinions etc. etc..
I’m a copywriter sans proper education and a writer sans proper education and as such, many things come to me like a feeling that something’s “not right”. Then I struggle with that feeling for a while until my brain arrives at some conclusion about the whole matter (and at that point, I become opinionated).
Now, the brain-arrival-time has come for the whole personal branding thing.
I’m thinking that, if we’re looking at literary marketing, it’s pretty similar to that of any other product. A book appeals to certain audience, and that audience is who the author wants to talk to. It’s really that simple.
If I’m producing and selling pink fluffy purses, I’m going to have a website that says “Hi Sweetheart!”. If I’m producing and selling steel-toed army boots, I’m banishing the idea of “Sweetheart” from that website. If I’m trying to be smart and design pink fluffy steel-toed army boots, I’d probably say “Sweetheart, go kick their sorry asses!”. I am not doing a research on 15-year-old girls and conclude that most of them respond well to “Hello there”, because I’m not talking ot most of them, I’m talking to a select few, the ones who’d be willing to buy my product.
So, well, for personal branding a writer has to figure out what sort of product does she write (not “would like to write” or “should write”… there’s no market for whipcream that wanted to be butter), what sort of person is the reader of these stories, and what sort of language does this reader appreciate.
The good news is that if you’re writing what you really want to write, chances are your normal speaking voice is very much like the voice you should be using when talking to your readers. Eg if you’re a cynical person writing cynical stories, your reader wouldn’t mind if you were cynical in your blog. Or, if you are a cute person writing sweet stories, the reader who is nauseated by your cutiepie blog would not enjoy your books, so you don’t need to appeal to that reader at all.
The bad news is that there’s nothing harder than defining yourself and the stories you’re writing outside the useless marketing terms. But that’s, I guess, a subject of another post.

Oho, I never suspected that they give this kind of advice to writers. Interesting – do the same recommendations, e.g. not having too strong opions apply to the contents of books. It is certainly like they do for products with the primary objective to catch as large a number of customers as possible. That’s why fast food, most modern compact class cars and major political parties’ programs are so alike and boring.
Also reminds me the novel “T” by Viktor Pelevin where the publisher took a loan and hired a team of writers each specialized in a particular area – action, erotics, etc. They follow what they know sells in their respective “fields of expertise” and together do the best to come up with a single novel that will be able to recover the the loan plus produce profit. Moreover they negotiate with the Orthodox church to make it pay if christianity is to be shown in an attractive light there. I was reading and thinking to what extent that’s how the industry works…
Anyway I would be hardly interested in an author who were purposfully polished to meet the median consumer like Big Mac or Volkswagen Golf.
what google says: Don’t be an ass
Basically, it’s not a bad advice, only ineffective as it’s given. I doubt somebody who’s a genuine ass would stop being an ass because a nice woman on Internet told him so. He could stop *acting* like an ass and start backstabbing people instead. But that’s another discussion altogether.
Here’s an interesting blog post on romance as a genre and what do romance writers/readers “say” about social roles of people. IMO, a prime example of marketing-and-message approach to writing. I could very well imagine this sort of post being written about Axe, Dove etc advertisements, but when it’s written about books it creeps me out a bit.
Of course, it’s romance, which is very restricted by marketing (don’t ask me why), SF/fantasy, for example, can afford to be way more daring.